Sea Grass vs Old Factory Shade: Which 12 Inch Shade to Pick
By Industville Official - Modern, Retro, Industrial Lighting | Published: 2026-11-05
Category: 비교
Compare the Sea Grass Fluted Slope and Old Factory 12 inch shades: woven natural texture versus metal finish options, and which shade-only pendant suits your room.
Quick answer
Choose the Sea Grass Fluted Slope 12 inch shade if you want a woven, natural texture that softens light and suits relaxed or coastal interiors. Choose the Old Factory 12 inch shade if you need a metal finish to match existing hardware or prefer a more industrial look.
Material and light character
The Sea Grass shade is woven from natural sea grass around a solid frame, creating a fluted, sloping form. That weave produces a subtle wave pattern that guides light downwards and outward, which makes it a good fit where you want softer, textured illumination rather than a sharp pool of light. The Old Factory shade is a metal design available in Pewter, Copper, Pewter & Copper, Light Pewter, and Brass finishes. Metal shades typically give a more direct, focused light output, so they suit task areas or rooms where you want a crisper look. Neither product listing specifies a light output or beam angle, so treat the material difference as a styling and ambiance choice rather than a performance guarantee.
Finish and styling flexibility
The Old Factory shade offers five finish options, which makes it easier to coordinate with pendant holders, cabinet hardware, or existing metal fixtures in a room. The Sea Grass shade comes in a single natural finish, so it works best when you want the weave itself to be the focal point. If your room already has mixed metals or you are matching a specific tone, the Old Factory range gives you more control. If you are building a layered, natural look with wood, rattan, or linen, the Sea Grass shade will sit more comfortably.
Shade-only compatibility
Both are shade-only products, so you will need a compatible pendant holder or fitting. The Sea Grass shade is designed to pair with a variety of pendant holders including Knurled, Sleek, and Brooklyn styles. The Old Factory shade listing notes that compatible shades can be found in the Specifications table, but the specific holder types are not listed here. Before ordering the Old Factory shade, check the specifications table on its product page to confirm it fits your existing holder. This is the main practical difference: the Sea Grass shade names its compatible holder families, while the Old Factory shade requires a specification check.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Natural texture vs metal finish: The Sea Grass shade brings a woven, organic look that softens light, but it comes in one natural finish. The Old Factory shade offers five metal finishes for matching hardware, but its metal surface gives a more direct light character. Decide first whether texture or finish coordination matters more in your room.
- Holder compatibility check: The Sea Grass shade is designed for Knurled, Sleek, and Brooklyn pendant holders. The Old Factory shade requires you to check the Specifications table for compatible holders before ordering. If you already own a pendant holder, confirm fit before buying either shade.
- Style direction: Choose Sea Grass for coastal, boho, or layered natural interiors. Choose Old Factory for industrial, modern, or metal-accented rooms where a crisp finish is the priority. Match the shade material to the dominant finishes already in the room.
Product facts
- Sea Grass Fluted Slope - 12 Inch - Natural - Shade Only: Crafted from woven natural sea grass, fluted into a sloping form that softens the light. The woven texture diffuses light and adds a natural, tactile element that suits relaxed and coastal schemes.
Sea Grass Fluted Slope - 12 Inch - Natural - Shade Only - Old Factory - 12 Inch - Shade Only: Available in Pewter, Copper, Pewter & Copper, Light Pewter, and Brass finishes. Multiple metal finishes let you match existing hardware or pendant holders more precisely.
Old Factory - 12 Inch - Shade Only
Which shade is right for you?
Best for
- Rooms with wood, rattan, or linen where a woven texture adds warmth
- Pendant holders from the Knurled, Sleek, or Brooklyn ranges
- Anyone who wants softer, diffused light from a shade-only pendant
Not for
- Spaces where you need to match a specific metal finish such as brass or copper
- Pendant holders that are not listed as compatible with the Sea Grass shade
- Anyone who prefers a crisp, industrial metal look over natural texture
